Minister
“That Sinking Feeling”
Matthew 14: 22-33
To join with us by watching our online worship, please click here.
“Immediately [Jesus] made the disciples get into the boat and go on ahead to the other side, while he dismissed the crowds.” (Matt 14: 22) Immediately after offering the ‘sermon on the mount’, immediately after feeding the 5000 people who had come to see him, more if you count the women and children, immediately afterwards, Jesus wants time to rest and to pray. Something for us to note – even Jesus took time out.
So, he makes the disciples get on the boat and set sail for the other side of the lake, and sends the crowd back to their homes. Notice he ‘makes’ the disciples go; it would appear some coercion was needed to get them to leave. A more accurate translation of ‘makes’ is ‘to force’ or ‘to compel’. Maybe the disciples didn’t want to leave Jesus’ side. Or maybe, they could see a storm was brewing. They were after all seasoned fishermen, familiar with the sea and the skies and the wind and the waves. But nevertheless, he makes them go. As happens to all of us at some point, they are sent off with perhaps a not so gentle a push, propelled towards adventures and risks they and we would rather avoid.
By the time evening rolled around a storm had indeed come in and the boat was being battered and beaten by the waves. Somehow, in the wee hours of the morning, perhaps aware of the disciples’ distress, aware of the possible danger, Jesus leaves his quiet place and walks across the water towards the vessel. The disciples see a figure approaching, but in the late hour and the high seas they think he is a ghost, and they cry out in fear. Jesus calls out to them: “Take heart, it is I; do not be afraid. Peter answered him ‘Lord, if it is you, command me to come to you on the water.’ [And Jesus said] ‘Come’.” Emboldened by this call Peter got out of the boat and walked on the water towards Jesus. “But when he noticed the strong wind, he became frightened, and beginning to sink, he cried out, “Lord, save me!’” (Matt 14: 30)
Poor Peter. He wants to be faithful. He steps out of the boat in faith, makes some headway towards Jesus, but then, he falters. He notices the danger all around him, the improbability of pulling off this venture, and he begins to sink. But at least he tries. At least he takes a chance in faith.
Some of us have heard this story so often that like many Bible stories, it has become domesticated. We know how it’s going to go for Peter, and we often underestimate how courageous he was to even try. The terror of Peter and the others is very well placed when we remember that in the time and place of Jesus, the sea was considered the locus, the very centre of chaos and evil. In Genesis, in the first words of the Bible, God’s opening act was to bring order to the ‘formless void’ of a watery creation, to bring order to the chaos. And from there and throughout Scripture the sea continues to require God’s hand to still it and God’s presence to keep those safe who venture upon it. In Jesus’ time and place the waters are a place of peril, of potential chaos and death. Of course the fishers were afraid.
In the many stories of God and God in Christ we see that it is particularly in times of great uncertainty and upheaval that God comes to us. When our boat is on smooth waters we don’t have much of an awareness of our need for God, and we often miss sightings of the holy all around us. It is in times of tumult and terror, upheaval and uncertainty that we reach out to God, and it is in those times when we catch glimpses of how God reaches out towards us, to calm our torment, to still our hearts and minds. In the darkest and most turbulent times of our lives God in Christ reaches out to us as a parent embraces a child locked in a nightmare. “Take heart, it is I. Do not be afraid.”
Psychologist Brene Brown has said that we are so afraid of disappointment, heart break and shame, that we try to beat them to the punch by refusing to be vulnerable. We decline to try anything risky in order to avoid experiencing difficult emotions. We live in what she calls ‘foreboding joy’. In anticipation that something bad is going to happen at any moment, so we don’t set our hearts on anything, we don’t risk a great venture. We don’t risk hope. I’d add that we don’t rely on faith. But, in avoiding vulnerability, Brene Brown says, we also give up joy. (Brene Brown, YouTube “Shame, Vulnerability, Whole Hearted Lives”) At least Peter makes an effort, time and again putting himself at risk for failure. Embracing both the joy of Christ’s presence and call, and the painful vulnerability of the possibility of our own falling short, or feeling let down by God.
As Peter began to sink “Jesus immediately reached out his hand and caught him, saying to him, ‘You of little faith, why did you doubt?’” This response of Jesus’ might be just why we don’t risk much – who wants to be chided by or a disappointment to Jesus? That’s going to ratchet up our ‘foreboding joy’ isn’t it? We’re hesitant to offer too much trust in or gratitude to God just in case our faith falters and we hear the ‘tsk tsk’ of holy disappointment, if not mockery. But maybe, maybe, what we hear in Jesus’ voice, ‘you of little faith’ is more of an affectionate term of endearment.
An article I read pointed out that Jesus only referred to his disciples, truly his chosen ones, as ‘oligopistoi’, little faith ones. In the article the writer suggests that perhaps oligopistoi is a term of endearment, of familiarity if not affection; a kind of bantering or teasing that Jesus only uses with his disciples, with those closest to him. (James R Adams, Jesus and His Friends of Little Faith, Progressivechristianity.org)
And maybe it’s an acknowledgment by Jesus, his little faith ones, that we just can’t carry around great quantities of faith, and we can’t just conjure it up. Faith is something that is given to us, it is offered and grows within us. In her poem “A Strong Woman” Marge Piercy writes, “Strength is not in her, but she enacts it as the wind fills a sail.” Maybe, another artist writes, “…[faith] doesn’t reside solely in us, waiting for us to muster it, but it comes as we open ourselves to it, unfurling ourselves to be moved by it, to be propelled, to leave the familiar places we have known and to let go of our accustomed ways of moving through the world.” (Jan Richardson, Painted Prayerbook 2011/07/31) “Oh you of little faith” then isn’t an admonishment, but a reminder that we can open ourselves up, unfurl our sails and let our souls be filled with a faith that is offered by God, not generated by our will alone.
At 74 and after more than 30 years in ministry I can testify to the truth that faith is offered to us when we stand before a great challenge with empty hands and heart. God has many times pushed me out beyond not only my comfort zone, but what I would have said was my capacity to cope, and given this ‘one of little faith’ all that I needed to serve God in the moment. Indeed, it was God who had faith in me, reaching out and stilling the chaos as I was about to sink below the waves.
Years ago I presided at the memorial for a 23-year-old young man who was killed in a car accident. There was an open casket at the front of the chapel. As I sat with his mother and siblings, with the casket in front of us, I could feel how God stills the chaos, how even if it is only through the gift of shock, the surviving beloveds are wrapped in a compassion that is tight enough to prevent them from flying apart into nothingness. I confess that I could feel myself sinking as I stood by the young man…how can someone so beautiful be so dead? And then I watched in awe as the wind of faith filled the sails of those around me. The family and so-young friends were able to stand up and gather around the casket. And tell stories, and sob and laugh. And marvel at how their friend looked, and teeter on the existential edge of gazing upon someone you love who is now dead. Who is there in all his beauty but is gone in all his glory.
And I watched as the mother and the boy’s siblings hastened to embrace the boy who was driving the car at the time of the accident, hastened to make sure he knew he was loved, that he was held in their embrace. I watched this same boy’s young friends wrap their burly tattooed arms around him and hold him up – claiming him in a fierce community of grace. These people had their own miracles going on, no less amazing than Peter’s ability to walk on water towards God. Before my very eyes the mourners moved through chaos and wild tumultuous grief and they did not sink. But were able to stand together and be a huddled bundle of grace and hope and a sustaining faith, perhaps even unconsciously, unbeknownst to them offered by God, that life would go on.
Faith is not an intellectual exercise, or a quality that can be summoned by personal rigour and discipline. It is a lifesaving force, graciously given. As the Holy grasps our hand and our heart while saying, ‘I’m here, hold on’, may we also be instruments of that holy force, part of the wind that fills the sails of all creation. Amen