Minister
“No Prenuptials”
Mark 10: 17-27
To join with us by watching our online worship, please click here.
Many years ago, on the eve of the long Thanksgiving weekend, I had a little financial meltdown. First of all, I learned to my chagrin that my brand new, no-limit American Express card, indeed did have a limit. When I called to ask why I had trouble paying for something, I was told that there actually was a limit on how much I could spend until I had established a credit history over six months. They added to my frustration by saying that even if I went online to make a payment – it wouldn’t be acknowledged for 5-6 business days. Never mind I thought to myself, I’ll use Visa. Well, it wouldn’t work either. I knew my husband had paid off the balance before we got the bill earlier in the month and so hadn’t turned my attention to the bill when it came. I therefore missed the fact that there was a tiny bit outstanding, and I was past the due date. Now, that $50 stood between me and the plans for the weekend that entailed having access to money.
I was in Seattle with our youngest son. In a hotel. Eating at restaurants. Shopping. Our eldest son had called to say he was unexpectedly on leave and could come home – but didn’t have money for a flight. Bob was working in Kuala Lampur, which meant I needed to get it all sorted out by myself. I’m not going to bore you with more of the futile steps I took floundering around trying to access my money, suffice it to say I felt so frightened, so out of control, so stupid. For a brief period of time, I felt a bit like the rich man in the story of Mark today; faced without the usual methods of organizing and controlling my life I was completely disoriented.
The rich young man came to Jesus, fell to his knees and asked what he must do to inherit eternal life. Jesus is at first not very sympathetic. He offers an answer that would have been obvious to any faithful Jew – you shall not murder, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not steal, etc. Jesus’ first response to the question about how to attain eternal life is obvious, he is reciting some of the Ten Commandments.
And then, the tone of the narrative changes. The man, maybe still on his knees, perhaps with pathos in his voice says; “I’ve kept the rules all my life; all my life I’ve followed the predictable path, lived in the rut of religious routine. And yet, I’m still missing something. I still need to ask, what must I do to have life in God?”
Now he has Jesus’ attention. Mark writes: “Jesus, looking at him, loved him…” Jesus looks at him. He looks at him and he looks into him. He sees the desire for more. He sees the yearning for more, the irrepressible longing, the hunger, the yawning gap in our hearts and souls that can only be filled by a relationship with the holy. And says: “You lack one thing; go, sell what you own, and give the money to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; then come, follow me.’”
And the rich man rose from his knees, and in shock and grief withdrew from the presence of Jesus. The one yearning for love, perhaps knowing already that he was in love, turned and walked away. Unable to give what was asked, unable to give up his life in order to receive life in God.
The disciples, Mark says rather politely, were perplexed.
No kidding they were perplexed. They were probably more accurately standing around in gap-mouthed shock. The rich man had been faithful, had followed all the commandments, had done all the right things, and he wasn’t assured of eternal life? Hadn’t he done all he could do to make sure he would get keys to the kingdom? Jesus doesn’t make it any easier for them, or for us. “Children, …it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God.” Which might kind of leave those of us comfortably settled on the North Shore or nearby just a little short of breath.
How do I have eternal life? Not by following the rules, but by breaking free. By breaking free of all that we hold most dear. By letting go of those possessions that have a peculiar way of possessing us, of weighing us down. By letting them go and lightening our load and allowing ourselves to be pulled into the realm of God.
Living in the kindom of God, on earth and in whatever realm we move to upon our death, is not about giving up the money and possessions. It’s about giving up the sense of control, of the trust, that we place in money, in careers, in connections, even the trust we place in following the rules of Scripture. It’s about instead trusting in God and God alone. It’s about not trying to make our gospel so organized that we can follow it easily, because it’s complex and crazy and often just doesn’t make sense on this side of the grave. Jesus had come and is here now to roust us out of the ruts of our brains and our faith; to wash out the clearly defined road so we cannot predict the wild grace of God and can only follow the road by watching constantly for where God is. God comes in Jesus to destabilize a people who prefer stability – it’s no wonder that they killed him.
Over the years we’ve tried to tidy up this scandalous story. I’m not going to go in to all the ideas about what a camel passing through the eye of a needle might mean, there have been many efforts to domesticate it, to minimize the difficulty of the passage. Scholars and we want to make Scripture make sense so that God makes sense, so that we can get a grip on the ineffable, impossible to grasp nature of God.
We try to get around the fact that there is nothing we can DO to enter into life in God except to fall backwards like a child into a pool, trusting that the water will catch us, that the arms of God will enfold us and that we’ll be OK.
We don’t want to be consumed by the chaos and vagaries of life, to be overcome by the unexpected and the disappointing and heart-breaking and the downright injustice of life and so we try to twist order into the disordered nature of the world, and at the same time we try to make rational and reasonable God’s unrelenting love for us and pursuit of us.
But God’s love, God’s grace, run rough shod over any sense of orderly faith, any sense of predictability based on following the rules, any way of understanding entitlement. It’s a destabilizing love and grace, and we’ll do almost anything to resist the disorientation that it brings. To resist giving up our control and trusting in the Holy Mystery.
Jesus is trying to get us into a life-giving relationship with God and we’re holding out for a prenuptial agreement.
I’ll commit my life to you God if I can keep all my security and control and if you can promise me that nothing will change. But God refuses to sign. I’ll give you everything, if you’ll fall into me, if you fall into love with me and not into your own sense of power and control. The rich man wanted to love God, and more than anything he wanted to know that God loved him. But he wasn’t willing to risk it all. He wasn’t willing to lean into the heady, wild, unpredictable chaos of life counting only on the love and grace of God. He let his Lover go, because he couldn’t trust that their love came so freely, without designs on his money but only designs on his life.
This passage is not saying that we’ll be guaranteed life eternal in God if we just sell everything and give it to the poor. Can you see how that is just one more way of trying to domesticate our faith? One more way of trying to make predictable the path of God? To be clear, it’s also not saying that God will love you more if you drive yourself into poverty so that you can donate more to the mission of Mount Seymour. Thank you, but no.
Jesus is saying at 4:45 on the Friday of a long weekend cut up all your credit cards, shred all your cheques, remove yourself from your friends and partners and anyone else who can save you, leave yourself wildly open and wondering what the hell you’re going to do – and then we can talk. And then maybe there’ll be a little, tiny opening with some room for vulnerability and wondering and hoping and trusting in God.
Now – here’s the good news, the really good news. The disciples know how hard, perhaps impossible this is for people of their time and we know how hard, impossible, it is for us. How this could sound like we don’t have a hope in hell of getting into heaven. But Jesus offers consolation: “For mortals it is impossible, but not for God; for God all things are possible.” (Mark 10: 27) Make your best effort, but I’ve got your back no matter what.
Jesus never said the economy of God made sense. He did and does say that in the economy of God all things are possible, including eternal life in the love of God. Thanks be to God. Amen